Bepanthen Vs. Sudocrem? Nappy Rash Ointment Review

I think that most people with tattoos have probably heard of using Bepanthen as a repairing aftercare cream.  So I kind of chuckled at having to use the product for its actual purpose: a nappy rash ointment.  I happily received my samples of Bepanthen from The Insiders a couple of weeks ago and I was happy to try it out because I had been using another brand of nappy rash cream (Sudocrem) ever since Oscar’s birth.  While I was happy with Sudocrem, I hadn’t used any other brands so I thought it would be interesting to see the differences.

Our samples of Bepanthen from The Insiders - thank you!

When Oscar was about 2 months old he started getting nappy rash.  I had no idea it was nappy rash for about a week!  It looked nothing like what a ‘rash’ in my mind looked like to be honest, there were small white bumps (slightly like white heads) around the bum, but it wasn’t red and I didn’t think it looked sore.  After a few days without going away, I asked my GP who confirmed it was nappy rash afterall.  I honestly felt like a failure of a parent letting my little boy end up with these horrible spots on his super soft and sensitive newborn skin!

I was using Sudocrem at the time but never really knew how much I should be applying to be honest.  After increasing the amount used with permission by the GP it did go away after a week.  I hadn’t thought to switch brands either at the time as I had bought such a gigantic tub of it too so I’m glad it did do the trick in the end and when I think back now I think I wasn’t applying enough of it at nappy changes.  That is my only experience with nappy rash so far and it has not returned since then, luckily!

The Differences??

sudo vs ben.JPG

Now since I can only compare Bepanthen with what I have been using this whole time, I have made a short list of differences I discovered:

  • At home we use the tub of Sudocrem and after trying the tube with flip top cap of Bepanthen I do wonder if it is more hygienic using a tube.  However I do prefer a big pot of 400g over many tubes of plastic of 30g each (though these are perfect for the changing bag).  I have since found that there are also tubes of Sudocrem 30g at a pricy £4.19 (Boots) compared to Bepanthen 30g at £3.36.  The biggest available tube of Sudocrem is 100g for £9.99 (yikes) compared to Bepanthen 100g at £7.29.  However there is the 400g Sudocrem tub available at £5.99– why the tube costs so much more I do wonder!
  • Sudocrem is a lot thicker to apply on, and feels ‘drier’ compared to Bepanthen which is slightly stickier but goes on thin.
  • Sudocrem has a distinctive smell to it (perhaps a tiny bit medicinal but nothing bad), whereas Bepanthan is scentless but it is pleasant.
  • With both creams I found they are pretty thick.  But Sudocrem does kind of go into my nails and I have to wipe at it to get it off.  Sudocrem would probably stain a bit more too as it’s more white, but I have not experienced any problems myself with this.
  • Sudocrem can be used to dry out spots (we have tested this before at home with success!).  According to Google, Sudocrem is also good as a face mask, insect stings, chaffing, makeup primer and sunburn amongst other uses.  When I looked up other uses for Bepanthen, it said that the antibacterial properties are good for general healing and as a general moisturiser.  I also found out that it is not so good for tattoo healing any more (for a few years now maybe) due to the change in ingredients, so it is better to use specific tattoo healing products instead (we like Tattoo Goo).
img_1769.jpg
The mini samples we received of Bepanthen did not have a very child friendly cap, I was terrified Oscar would grab it and eat it as he puts most things into his mouth!

Conclusion?

It was tricky because there are pros and cons with both products.  We enjoyed Bepanthen and Oscar did not experience any nappy rash the past two weeks.  I think maybe his bum did appear slightly more moisturised at nappy changes with Bepanthen, as in, it stayed more ‘wet’.  I liked the tube which is perfect for the changing bag as I said.  And while the Sudocrem tub doesn’t seem that hygienic (if you keep double dipping into the tub), this can be avoided once you start working out how much you need to be applying (thicker than I thought was needed!).  The tub is convenient to open with one hand and have one hand on a wriggly baby.  I like the multiple uses of Sudocrem (you can read here about other baby products I love that serve multiple uses).

I don’t dislike any product over the other.  Sudocrem tube-version is more expensive than the Bepanthen tube (30g) but the big tub of Sudocrem is a lot more value over the 100g tube of Bepanthen.  You could say the Bepanthen needs less for each application but I think it still works out Sudocrem is better value for money if you are buying the big tub and using it for the other things it is good for as I listed above.

All in all, I think I will be keeping a tub of Sudocrem on my changing station at home and a tube of Bepanthen in my nappy changing bag from now on!! 🙂

ames sig1

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.